I-Ads Part Deux...

Hurricane09Hurricane09 Member Posts: 40
edited November -1 in iPhone and Android Publishing
Can't find the original I-Ads thread, so I started another. Just submitted an app tonight and it asked if I wanted to enable I-Ads, so I said yes... The process seemed to go fine - I'll update once approved.
«1

Comments

  • chosenonestudioschosenonestudios Member Posts: 1,714
    FYI ..... thats not going to work

    Sorry :/
  • PhoticsPhotics Member Posts: 4,172
    Hurricane09 said:
    Can't find the original I-Ads thread,

    It's over here...
    http://gamesalad.com/forums/topic.php?id=7316
  • Hurricane09Hurricane09 Member Posts: 40
    @chosenonestudios - whats not going to work? Do you have any other inside information? I read the other thread and it had no info whatsoever... I think Photics was giving away free sandwich recipes in the end. So have you tried uploading an app enabling IAds and it didn't work, or what are you basing the information on?
  • chosenonestudioschosenonestudios Member Posts: 1,714
    you actually have to enable code in your app...

    I.E. in xcode you have to add text...

    In GS its unfortunately not possible because we don't have an xcode project to edit... And Gendai has not added functionality.. like say when your publishing theirs not a checkbox that says iAds...

    Gendai probably wont add xcode editing for a long time... And they have not added iAd support so we'll have to wait till they do, so must likely your app will get rejected..

    If you really deem it necessary, I'll find a site talking about how to enable iAds in xcode apps or something of the sort... But I hope I made myself clear enough :)

    Alot of other people believe this is the case also.. Maybe I will just to quell those people down :D
  • Hurricane09Hurricane09 Member Posts: 40
    ugh, so should I re-upload then, or will they reject? Had the feeling I shouldn't have checked off that box...
  • chosenonestudioschosenonestudios Member Posts: 1,714
    Not exactly sure what will happen... They might just send you an email saying iAds was not enabled or something... Who knows..

    Trust me I wish this was the case also :/
  • Hurricane09Hurricane09 Member Posts: 40
    tough one to decide on - I'd like to publish as soon as possible (like all of us), especially since this one is World Cup related... if it was something else I might hang on just to see. Gendai - any advice?
  • Hurricane09Hurricane09 Member Posts: 40
    Just an update - my app was approved with i-Ads enabled. I'm wondering if this is like Google AdSense where you have to setup the site (in this case app) and then any clicks are referenced to that site/app. So you wouldn't necessarily have to have the i-Ad code in the application, but once you do the clicks would be tracked.
  • giacomopoppigiacomopoppi Member, PRO Posts: 914
    OH?? your app was accepted?
    did u check to see if there was iads?
  • RHRH Member Posts: 1,079
    Hurricane09 said:
    Just an update - my app was approved with i-Ads enabled. I'm wondering if this is like Google AdSense where you have to setup the site (in this case app) and then any clicks are referenced to that site/app. So you wouldn't necessarily have to have the i-Ad code in the application, but once you do the clicks would be tracked.

    WHAAT, are you getting paid for it?
  • JamesZeppelinJamesZeppelin Member Posts: 1,927
    The moral of this story is read apples documentation (instructions) first.

    :)
  • giacomopoppigiacomopoppi Member, PRO Posts: 914
    i havnt yet understood:
    can we use iads at this moment WITH GAMESALAD?
  • chosenonestudioschosenonestudios Member Posts: 1,714
    What??? Thats impossible what app is it??? Link Please?

    Hmmmm.... Also they might have approved it because iAds isnt live yet....

    99% sure when Aids goes live.... There will not be iAds in your app...

    I honestly haven't seen any iAd enabled apps yet, is there just a blank bar that says iAds or something??? Does it say that in your app also???
  • chosenonestudioschosenonestudios Member Posts: 1,714
    giacomopoppi said:
    i havnt yet understood:
    can we use iads at this moment WITH GAMESALAD?

    Doubt it, most likely its a misunderstanding, but we havnt seen any evidence from him yet so we'll see...
  • Hurricane09Hurricane09 Member Posts: 40
    Not saying I'll have i-Ads, because we don't have the ability to add the line of code we need into the app, but I was just giving an update on the fact that the app was not rejected even though I had selected to have i-Ads enabled when I submitted. I doubt it will even have the bar as I haven't put a placeholder in for that. I can't even check the app right now (at work), but if someone is able to check I can fire over a promo code.
  • chosenonestudioschosenonestudios Member Posts: 1,714
    I'll check right now:)
  • Hurricane09Hurricane09 Member Posts: 40
    Sure, here you go 44EPR3XEF3JJ

    On another note, this game was initially rejected because it had 'World Cup' as a keyword. The nice thing is all I had to do was remove the offensive keywords and reply to the email from Apple and they immediately had the app back in review and then approved it. No need to re-upload a binary or go back into the queue.
  • chosenonestudioschosenonestudios Member Posts: 1,714
    Just downloaded, "Attack of the Vuvuzela"

    See no black bars or anything... But Im not sure what Im looking for exactly... But it looks pretty regular unless its somewhere else I cant see..

    On a side note, cool game:) Kinda like whack-a-mole :D
  • Hurricane09Hurricane09 Member Posts: 40
    Thanks! It's not my best work, but I put it together in a couple hours to try to cash in on some of the vuvuzela buzz.

    I'm don't think it'll show anything with i-Ads since we don't have that capability, but how awesome could it be if we could just put an actor into our scenes that contained the code..(cough, cough)... I just wanted to post the results as we weren't sure if I would be rejected for enabling them, and as it turned out, I wasn't.
  • PhoticsPhotics Member Posts: 4,172
    As stated in the other iAds thread...
    After seeing how ridiculously easy it is to add iAds to an xcode app, there's simply no excuse for GameSalad to be sans iAds by the end of the month.
  • chosenonestudioschosenonestudios Member Posts: 1,714
    Photics said:
    As stated in the other iAds thread...

    After seeing how ridiculously easy it is to add iAds to an xcode app, there's simply no excuse for GameSalad to be sans iAds by the end of the month.

    Unless they're too busy doing stability *cough cough*
  • dingosmoovdingosmoov Member Posts: 130
    Not having the ability to add iAds to an app, could be the thing that gets GameSalad banned as a middleware tool.

    The gap in functionality from what is offered natively, and what third party tools decide to implement is exactly the problem that Steve Jobs was talking about. I think GameSalad is a great tool, BUT... we are at GameSalad's mercy in regards to what things they want to implement. And in the case of iAds it directly affects possible revenue.

    Please GameSalad gurus, please make this one a priority, before the boat is missed, or you get banned as a tool.
  • quantumsheepquantumsheep Member Posts: 8,188
    dingosmoov said:
    Not having the ability to add iAds to an app, could be the thing that gets GameSalad banned as a middleware tool.

    The gap in functionality from what is offered natively, and what third party tools decide to implement is exactly the problem that Steve Jobs was talking about. I think GameSalad is a great tool, BUT... we are at GameSalad's mercy in regards to what things they want to implement. And in the case of iAds it directly affects possible revenue.

    Please GameSalad gurus, please make this one a priority, before the boat is missed, or you get banned as a tool.

    I don't agree, especially about the middleware stuff.

    By that reckoning, any app, written natively or not, HAS to have iAds in it.

    That's just not true. There are plenty of devs that don't want to go anywhere near iAds.

    Cheers,

    QS :D

    Dr. Sam Beckett never returned home...
    Twitter: https://twitter.com/Quantum_Sheep
    Web: https://quantumsheep.itch.io

  • dingosmoovdingosmoov Member Posts: 130
    quantumsheep said:
    I don't agree, especially about the middleware stuff.

    By that reckoning, any app, written natively or not, HAS to have iAds in it.

    That's just not true. There are plenty of devs that don't want to go anywhere near iAds.

    Cheers,

    QS :D

    What I am saying is that any middleware tool will have to make it POSSIBLE to add iAds. If that tool does not make it possible to add iAds, then it runs the risk of being banned as a middleware tool.
  • quantumsheepquantumsheep Member Posts: 8,188
    Oh, right. Fair enough.

    QS.

    Dr. Sam Beckett never returned home...
    Twitter: https://twitter.com/Quantum_Sheep
    Web: https://quantumsheep.itch.io

  • JamesZeppelinJamesZeppelin Member Posts: 1,927
    quantumsheep said:
    I don't agree, especially about the middleware stuff.

    By that reckoning, any app, written natively or not, HAS to have iAds in it.

    That's just not true. There are plenty of devs that don't want to go anywhere near iAds.

    Cheers,

    QS :D

    I think the biggest change is the shovel ware will be free instead of .99
    Plus devs who want to advertise already do.
    FOr some reason people are treating iAds like adwords and admob didnt exsist.

    They are huge. WHen you use one your add gets a million impressions in like one day
  • firemaplegamesfiremaplegames Member Posts: 3,211
    Gendai did say that they are working on it. They actually need to get iOS 4.0 support before they can even implement iAds.

    iAds has only been out for a few days, I'm sure they need some time to test it.
  • BarkBarkCoBarkBarkCo Member Posts: 1,400
    dingosmoov (aka voice of the almighty Steve Jobs) said:
    What I am saying is that any middleware tool will have to make it POSSIBLE to add iAds. If that tool does not make it possible to add iAds, then it runs the risk of being banned as a middleware tool.
    How many API's is iOS 4 up to now? Wouldn't that be true for all of them?

    ...didn't think so. ;-)
  • dingosmoovdingosmoov Member Posts: 130
    JamesZeppelin said:
    I think the biggest change is the shovel ware will be free instead of .99
    Plus devs who want to advertise already do.
    FOr some reason people are treating iAds like adwords and admob didnt exsist.

    They are huge. WHen you use one your add gets a million impressions in like one day

    If you could put Admob into Gamesalad game that would be a great "stop-gap" til we could do iAds. My bet will be on iAds though. For the next year iAds will be paying out more revenue than Admob, etc. Because of the contracts that have been negotiated by Apple.

    Also remember iAds is Apple, Admob is Google. It is in Apple's best interest that iAds be the main platform for advertising into the i-echosystem: iPhone, iPad, iPod Touch.

    Again tools that make for easy seamless integration of iAds will be a feature that many developers using third party tools will be looking for.

    For months people requested a way to put in advertising, and nothing has happened on the the GameSalad front. I saw the post on the GameSalad blog about iOS4. Again I ask can you make iAds(or for that matter ANY advertising) a priority.
  • PPenguinPPenguin Member, PRO Posts: 110
    As an elite subscriber, I think the GS devs should realize that this is the single most-wanted feature that we've been waiting for.. I've been holding off on releasing a few apps, because I'm waiting for them to update with iAd support. You could say it's the equivalent of holding my breath for it.. :P For the amount of money I paid for the subscription, I don't think it's too much to ask, honestly.
Sign In or Register to comment.

© Vanilla Keystone Theme 2025